How do you comment on a thesis?

The following simple structure will help you present your comments in an organized way:

  1. Reflect back the paper’s main point.
  2. Discuss the essay’s strengths.
  3. Discuss the paper’s weaknesses, focusing on large problems first.
  4. Type your final comments if possible.

What do examiners look for in a thesis?

Examiners want to read a thesis where the candidate has used the literature to argue that: their interpretation of the field is accurate; their research question and approach are worthwhile, appropriate and address a significant gap in the literature; and their results and conclusions make an important contribution to …

How do you respond to examiner comments?

Responding to Examiners – Guidelines

  1. Make any corrections or revisions in your thesis using ‘Track Changes’.
  2. Your response to the examiners comments should be presented in a systematic manner using a tabular format in which you clearly indicate the comment to which you are responding and then give your response.

How do I choose a thesis examiner?

The most popular wisdom about examiner choice is that the supervisor and the PhD researcher look to see which scholars have been significant in the development of the thesis and approach them. This is fine as long as these people are not retired, deceased or inaccessible.

What are some positive comments?

Outstanding Good for you Phenomenal Good reasoning Praiseworthy Good thinking Prestigious work Good work/Good job Proper Grand Purrrfect Great Remarkable Great going Resounding results Honorable Respectable I appreciate your cooperation.

How do you comment on a statement?

Typical Tasks

  1. Comment (stating your own opinion) state your opinion and give examples and arguments that support your opinion.
  2. Compare. find common and distinct features.
  3. Criticize. find advantages and disadvantages.
  4. Discuss. analyse all aspects of a problem (What is …? / Is it okay to …?)
  5. Evaluate. analyse a problem.
  6. Justify.

How long does it take for examiner to read thesis?

Please note that examiners usually need between four and six weeks to read a thesis and prepare for the examination.

How do you evaluate a master’s thesis?

The following factors can be evaluated according to the scale: satisfactory/very satisfactory /good/very good /excellent, i.e. 1-5. The research scope has been defined. The goals of the thesis are evident. The research questions and hypotheses contained in the scope of research and goals are evident from the thesis.

Do PhD examiners read the whole thesis?

Many examiners develop their own tactics for how they approach a thesis. One popular strategy is to read the first and final chapter together, to gain an overall impression of the thesis; and only then to read the whole thing. But regardless of their approach, examiners don’t want to struggle to understand your points.

How do you give professional feedback?

7 Tips for Giving Constructive Feedback

  1. Focus on the issue. Proper constructive criticism should always focus on the situation or issue caused by the person, rather than focusing on the person’s character.
  2. Be sincere.
  3. Avoid the sandwich method.
  4. Be specific.
  5. Allow a response.
  6. Recommend a solution.
  7. Provide a summary.

How do you comment on a good report?

Work Habits

  1. is a conscientious, hard-working student.
  2. works independently.
  3. is a self-motivated student.
  4. consistently completes homework assignments.
  5. puts forth their best effort into homework assignments.
  6. exceeds expectations with the quality of their work.
  7. readily grasps new concepts and ideas.

How do you give good comments?

Complimenting the Whole Person

  1. I appreciate you.
  2. You are perfect just the way you are.
  3. You are enough.
  4. You’re all that and a super-size bag of chips.
  5. On a scale from 1 to 10, you’re an 11.
  6. You’ve got all the right moves.
  7. Everything would be better if more people were like you.
  8. You are an incredible human.

What is a comment example?

The definition of a comment is a statement or remark. An example of a comment is a statement released in the paper that someone made about a scandal going on.

How are masters thesis marked?

A Master’s thesis is graded on a seven-step scale from laudatur (highest) to approbatur (weakest). Each department can provide more accurate information on the major-specific criteria of thesis grading. The typical features of different grades are generic and can be applied in a way suitable for each major.

What happens after I submit my thesis?

The most common outcome is that the candidate is asked to make amendments to their thesis. In these cases, the PG Office will send you the Oral Exam Report (including the list of required amendments) and the date by which these are required to be completed.

What are the criteria for judging the worthiness of research paper?

Clarity, precision and economy of writing. Accurate use of academic language and writing conventions appropriate for the specific task. Good overall presentation of paper as appropriate to the task. citation style, use of headings, etc.

What is satisfactory in thesis?

* Grades (2) SATISFACTORY or (4) VERY GOOD: The thesis does not meet all the criteria of the grade above, as one or more of the weighted assessment criteria for the higher. grade are not met.

How is a PhD thesis evaluated?

PhD thesis evaluation process is initiated by submission of a thesis Synopsis, followed by the full thesis within 30 days of Synopsis submission. To be eligible to submit the Synopsis and Ph. D. thesis for evaluation, the candidate is required to have completed the course work as well as the comprehensive.

How do you write a feedback comment?

Here are a few tips about what you shouldn’t do, so you can make sure your feedback is both valuable and constructive:

  1. Don’t give them feedback if they don’t want it.
  2. Don’t make it personal.
  3. Don’t be rude or condescending.
  4. Don’t give them false hope.
  5. Don’t provide too much information or be careless with your response.

What are some examples of positive feedback?

17 examples of positive feedback

  • An employee is being a good team player.
  • An employee is working overtime.
  • An employee is doing high-quality work.
  • An employee recently took on new responsibilities.
  • An employee reached conflict resolution.
  • An employee met their goals.

How do you write a remark?

Narrative Comment To-Dos

  1. Start on a positive note.
  2. Stay focused on the student.
  3. Speak to the parent and the student.
  4. Give examples.
  5. Provide specific information across several different areas.
  6. Use academic jargon. Comments should be written in language that is easy to understand for both parents and students.

How do you comment on improvement?

Improvement

  1. ______ is continuing to grow in independence.
  2. ______ has improved steadily.
  3. ______ has been consistently progressing.
  4. ______ has shown a good attitude about trying to improve in ______.
  5. ______ seems eager to improve.
  6. ______ has shown strong growth in _______.
  7. ______ is making steady progress academically.

What are examples of comments?

An example of a comment is a statement released in the paper that someone made about a scandal going on. A spoken remark. I have no comment on that. To comment is to make a statement, remark or express an opinion.

How do you comment on a topic?

How do you give a comment?

Top ten tips for writing a great comment

  1. Read the article.
  2. Respond to the article.
  3. Read the other comments.
  4. Make it clear who you’re replying to.
  5. Use the return key.
  6. Avoid sarcasm.
  7. Avoid unnecessary acronyms.
  8. Use facts.